tomtyke's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Madness Amelioration]

i really liked it

for a first submission it's amazing, i really liked how the robot was animated and the robots vision at the end, and the bumping of the car really shows an eye for detail

but the quality at the start was a bit off, however seeing as you made up for it later, im not going to go into that

keep up the good work! :D

and omegasis, the lag was your fault, turn the quality down and get a better computer, it's not gdop's fault yours is bad >:|

GDop26 responds:

Yay somebody noticed some of the small details, I forget how many small details there actually are but my friends told me to not put them there because people wouldn't notice, but SOMEONE noticed one of them, :D. Anyways thanks for the review, they really help.
Oh god I love your icon :D

[Stickman Can't Fight 2]

great!

i really like how you've taken this series in the exact opposite direction of the mainstream stick fight animations, it's incredible refreshing and i enjoyed watching every second of it

now, onto the criticism, some of the motions felt disjointed, and i would recommend increasing your frame rate to get those nice smooth movements that look so good on stick men (you can still do the crazy fast action with high frame rate)

in addition to this, at the point where he was being hit by the pivot man, it didn't look like he was recoiling with enough force, as he was only slowly knocked back about 1 step, just make him sway more and it would look much more natural

and as has been said before, need to be longer, but aside from my petty gripes, I enjoyed it very much, 5/5, 9/10

and i am going to watch every one in the future, keep up the amazing work :D

guitan11 responds:

Thanks for the awesome review. I did actually took your advice and bumped up the frame rate for the other ones. I would love to hear what you have to say for the other ones that have been out after this one :D

[Madness Test Collab]

i like how it turned out

i really enjoyed watching the tests, as they're a good oportunity for people to stretch what they can do without the need for backstory or a narrative,
in addition to this, i really liked how Elvis' parts are improving, they maintain a chaotic atomosphere that i've come to expect yet remain smooth, something his prior animations have lacked, and while i'm a nooby animator, i can sure tell quality when i see it,
5/5 10/10 to all the colab members, keep up the great work, because i enjoy watching it :D

Tr3Yo responds:

Thanks for a good review:)

[Mad-Thirst]

%u0CA0.%u0CA0

why the hell did i watch this.... AND WHY AM I GIVING IT A 10!?!?

%u0CA0_%u0CA0

Crazymonkey154 responds:

I don't know, you tell me.....

[Nightmare Madness Trailer]

win

thats some prety sweet madness there, i like how you made the sprites yourself (i think you did anyway) and the explosions and gun effects were very nice as well, also good use of the view, it really creates a nice atmosphere in conjuncion with the music

Deathisawesome responds:

Yup, I made the sprites :) I'm glad you liked it, as you're epic yourself :D

[iGay]

lol

i liked it, though i did get a serious edds world vibe from it, keep up the good work :D

ThePivotsXXD responds:

Eddsworld is one of my greatest inspirations...i started out making fan videos of him then I eventually came up with my character "Pivots" and here e is today...

[Stick Combo Test]

not bad

not bad, try to add some particle effects and some terrain, but other than that i liked it. (i'm also at the stickman stage lol)

Whygemini92 responds:

thanks man, lol yeah im experimental with backgrounds/sounds/effects as well, just got to tweek a few thing then maybe add some in :S